Table 5 Overview of current status of all competency questions
Competency Question | Answered? | Implementation | Future work | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Specification | Rel. Logic Rules | Prob. Rules | Techn. Impl. | ||
Recommending a suitable activity given a certain profile | |||||
 CQ1.1 The ontology must be able to take preferences and aversions into account when recommending activities. | Yes | Social and duration preferences, activity aversions | 1 - 1 A – 1 - 1P |  |  |
 CQ1.2 The ontology must be able to take sociodemographic factors (age, gender, socio-economic status, employment status, household composition) into account when recommending activities. | Partially | No expensive activities for people with below average income | 1 - 1 A – 1 - 1P | X |  |
 CQ1.3 The ontology must be able to take prior experience with certain activities into account when recommending activities. | No |  | 1 - 1 A – 1 - 1P |  | X |
 CQ1.4 The ontology must be able to take the current fitness level into account when recommending activities. | Yes | No high intensity activities for people with low fitness | 1 - 1 A – 1 - 1P |  |  |
Recommending a suitable context given a certain profile and activity | |||||
 CQ2.1 The ontology must know which locations are appropriate for which activity. | Yes | Possible locations and space mapped per activity | Implemented via object properties |  |  |
 CQ2.2 The ontology must know which social context is appropriate for which activity. | Yes | Possible social context mapped per activity | Implemented via object properties |  |  |
 CQ2.3 The ontology must know how long different activities take. | Yes | Minimum duration mapped per activity | Implemented via object properties |  |  |
 CQ2.4 The ontology must take the weather into account when recommending activities. | No |  |  |  | X |
 CQ2.5 The ontology must take daylight into account when recommending activities. | No |  |  |  | X |
Recommending suitable barriers given a certain profile, activity and context | |||||
 CQ3.1 The ontology must take sociodemographic factors (age, gender, SES) into account when recommending potential barriers. | Partially | Gender-specific barrier (e.g. menstrual pain) | 3–4 | X |  |
 CQ3.1a The ontology must take other responsibilities (work, household, childcare) into account when recommending barriers. | No |  |  | X |  |
 CQ3.2 The ontology must take characteristics of the planned activity into account when recommending potential barriers. | Yes | Barriers based on required experience, material | 3–5, 3–7 |  |  |
 CQ3.3 The ontology must take location characteristics into account when recommending potential barriers. | Yes | Barriers based on activity type and space (outside/inside) | 3 - 1, 3 - 2, 3 - 3 |  |  |
 CQ3.4 The ontology must take social context characteristics into account when recommending potential barriers. | Yes | Barriers based on social context and possible social context | 3 - 6 A, 3 - 6B |  |  |
 CQ3.5 The ontology must take temporal context characteristics into account when recommending potential barriers. | No | Barriers based on activity duration |  | X | X |
Recommending suitable coping strategies provided profile, activity, context and barriers | |||||
 CQ4.1 The ontology must know which coping strategies are relevant for which sociodemographic groups. | No | Strategy involving pets only if individual has pets | 4–23 | X |  |
 CQ4.1a The ontology must be able to take other responsibilities (work, household, childcare) into account when recommending barriers. | No |  |  | X |  |
 CQ4.2 The ontology must be able to take characteristics of the planned activity into account when recommending potential coping strategies. | Yes | Based on possible social context, equipped material, intensity | 4 - 19 A-C, 4 - 20 A-D, 4 - 22 A-B |  |  |
 CQ4.3 The ontology must be able to take location characteristics into account when recommending potential coping strategies. | Yes | Some coping strategies only for indoor or only for outdoor activities | 4–16, 4–17, 4–18 |  |  |
 CQ4.4 The ontology must be able to take social context characteristics into account when recommending potential coping strategies. | Yes | Some coping strategies only for solo or only for group activities | 4–16, 4–17, 4–18 |  |  |
 CQ4.5 The ontology must be able to take temporal context characteristics into account when recommending potential coping strategies. | Partially | Based on planned duration | 4 - 21 A-D |  | X |
 CQ4.6 The ontology must know which coping strategies are relevant for which barriers. | Yes | One on one mapping of barriers to coping strategies | 4 - 2– 4 - 15B |  |  |